MathIsimple

Probability & Statistics – Problem 2: Determine which statements are correct (multiple choice): A

Question

A bag contains 4 balls of identical size and texture: 2 white and 2 black. Two draws are made in sequence with replacement.

Event A (Jia): the first draw is white.

Event B (Yi): the second draw is black.

Event C (Bing): both draws are white.

Determine which statements are correct (multiple choice):

A. Events A and B are mutually exclusive.

B. Events B and C are mutually exclusive.

C. Events A and B are independent.

D. Events A and B are complementary.

Step-by-step solution

With replacement, the equally likely outcomes are {WW,WB,BW,BB}.\{WW,WB,BW,BB\}.

1) A and B can occur together (outcome WBWB), so they are not mutually exclusive. Therefore A is false.

2) B means the second draw is black, while C means both draws are white; they cannot occur simultaneously. Therefore B is true.

3) Let A be "first white" and B be "second black": P(A)=12,P(B)=12,P(AB)=P(WB)=14.P(A)=\frac12,\quad P(B)=\frac12,\quad P(AB)=P(WB)=\frac14. Since P(AB)=P(A)P(B),P(AB)=P(A)P(B), A and B are independent, so C is true.

4) Complementary events must be mutually exclusive and exhaustive. A and B are not mutually exclusive, so D is false.

Hence the correct options are B,CB,C.

Final answer

Because the sampling is with replacement, the four outcomes WW,WB,BW,BBWW,WB,BW,BB are equally likely. Events A and B are not mutually exclusive (they overlap at WBWB), but they are independent since P(AB)=14=P(A)P(B)P(AB)=\frac14=P(A)P(B).

Event B and event C are mutually exclusive, while A and B are not complementary because they are neither disjoint nor exhaustive as a pair.

Therefore, the correct option set is B,CB,C.

Marking scheme

1. Checkpoints (max 7 pts total)

Single chain for event-relation judgment (7 pts)

  • Enumerate/sample-space model for two draws with replacement. (1.5 pts)
  • Correctly judge A using a counterexample intersection outcome. (1 pt)
  • Correctly judge B using incompatibility of event definitions. (1 pt)
  • Compute P(A),P(B),P(AB)P(A),P(B),P(AB) and verify independence for C. (2 pts)
  • Explain why D is false using the definition of complementary events. (1 pt)
  • State final option set BCBC. (0.5 pt)

Total (max 7)


2. Zero-credit items

  • Giving only intuitive statements like “seems independent” without probability check.
  • Confusing “mutually exclusive” and “independent” definitions.

3. Deductions

  • Definition confusion (-1): treating complementary events as merely “different events”.
  • Probability arithmetic slip (-1): wrong P(AB)P(AB) under replacement model.
Ask AI ✨