MathIsimple

Solid Geometry – Problem 11: Prove that

Question

In a regular tetrahedron SXYZWSXYZW (all edges equal), let AA and BB be the midpoints of edges SXSX and SYSY, respectively. Let CC and DD be the midpoints of edges WXWX and WYWY, respectively.

(1) Prove that ABCDAB\parallel CD.

(2) Find the angle between segments ABAB and CDCD.

Step-by-step solution

Use vectors in R3\mathbb R^3. Choose an origin OO and denote the position vectors of S,X,Y,WS,X,Y,W by s,x,y,w\vec s,\vec x,\vec y,\vec w. Because A,B,C,DA,B,C,D are midpoints, a=s+x2,b=s+y2,c=w+x2,d=w+y2.\vec a=\frac{\vec s+\vec x}{2},\quad \vec b=\frac{\vec s+\vec y}{2},\quad \vec c=\frac{\vec w+\vec x}{2},\quad \vec d=\frac{\vec w+\vec y}{2}. Then AB=ba=yx2,\overrightarrow{AB}=\vec b-\vec a=\frac{\vec y-\vec x}{2}, and CD=dc=yx2.\overrightarrow{CD}=\vec d-\vec c=\frac{\vec y-\vec x}{2}. So AB=CD\overrightarrow{AB}=\overrightarrow{CD}, which implies ABCD.AB\parallel CD. Therefore the angle between ABAB and CDCD is 0.0^\circ.

Final answer

ABCDAB\parallel CD, so the angle between ABAB and CDCD is 00^\circ.

Marking scheme

1. Checkpoints (max 7 pts total)

  • Vector setup (2 pts): Introduce position vectors and write midpoint vectors correctly.
  • Direction computation (3 pts): Compute AB\overrightarrow{AB} and CD\overrightarrow{CD} and show they are equal (or proportional).
  • Conclusion (2 pts): State ABCDAB\parallel CD and give the angle 00^\circ.

2. Zero-credit items

  • Quoting the midpoint theorem without any vector/coordinate expression.
  • Writing midpoint vectors incorrectly (e.g., missing the 12\frac12 factor).

3. Deductions

  • Vector subtraction sign error (-1): swapping x\vec x and y\vec y leading to a wrong direction.
  • Parallel criterion omitted (-1): failing to connect AB=kCD\overrightarrow{AB}=k\overrightarrow{CD} to parallelism.
Ask AI ✨