Question
In a plane quadrilateral , suppose , , and . When the length of the diagonal is minimized, determine the range of .
Step-by-step solution
Step 1. In , by the Law of Cosines With and , we get .
Step 2. For fixed , we have , with equality when . Hence , so .
Step 3. In , . By the Law of Sines, So .
Step 4. Also .
Step 5. Therefore
Step 6. Since , we have , so .
Step 7. Hence .
Final answer
Marking scheme
1. Checkpoints (max 7 pts total)
Chain A: Law of Sines approach
- Set up side-angle relations [2 pts]: States and correctly advances the key derivation steps
- Substitute and simplify [2 pts]: Substitutes correctly and simplifies accurately
- Handle multiple cases / admissibility [1 pt]: Considers branches and rejects invalid cases
- Conclusion and verification [1 pt]: States the conclusion and checks against constraints
- Final answer [1 pt]: Gives the correct final result (for multiple-choice, include the option letter)
2. Zero-credit items
- Copies formulas without concrete substitution or derivation
- Guesses the answer / provides only a conclusion with no reasoning
- Uses an approach incompatible with the problem conditions, leading to an invalid conclusion
3. Deductions
- Computation error [-1]: Incorrect algebraic/trigonometric manipulation
- Logical gap [-1]: Missing a key equivalence step or a necessary condition check
- Nonstandard final statement [-1]: Missing units/range/option letter or wrong answer format