MathIsimple

Solid Geometry – Problem 22: Find and that maximize the cone’s volume, and give the maximum volume

Question

A right circular cone is inscribed in a sphere of radius RR. The cone’s axis passes through the sphere center, and its vertex is at the “north pole” of the sphere. Let hh be the cone’s height and rr its base radius.

(1) Express rr in terms of hh and RR.

(2) Find hh and rr that maximize the cone’s volume, and give the maximum volume.

Step-by-step solution

Set up a coordinate system with the sphere center OO at the origin and the axis as the zz-axis. Then the sphere is x2+y2+z2=R2.x^2+y^2+z^2=R^2. Let the cone’s vertex be V(0,0,R)V(0,0,R). If the cone has height hh, then its base plane is z=Rh.z=R-h. The base circle lies on the sphere, so at z=Rhz=R-h we have r2=x2+y2=R2(Rh)2=2Rhh2.r^2=x^2+y^2=R^2-(R-h)^2=2Rh-h^2. This proves (1).

(2) The cone volume is V(h)=13πr2h=13π(2Rhh2)h=13π(2Rh2h3),0<h<2R.V(h)=\frac13\pi r^2h=\frac13\pi(2Rh-h^2)h=\frac13\pi(2Rh^2-h^3),\qquad 0<h<2R. Differentiate: V(h)=13π(4Rh3h2)=13πh(4R3h).V'(h)=\frac13\pi(4Rh-3h^2)=\frac13\pi h(4R-3h). So the maximum occurs at h=4R3h=\frac{4R}{3}. Substitute into r2=2Rhh2r^2=2Rh-h^2: r2=2R4R3(4R3)2=8R29,r=223R.r^2=2R\cdot\frac{4R}{3}-\left(\frac{4R}{3}\right)^2=\frac{8R^2}{9},\quad r=\frac{2\sqrt2}{3}R. The maximum volume is Vmax=13π8R294R3=3281πR3.V_{\max}=\frac13\pi\cdot\frac{8R^2}{9}\cdot\frac{4R}{3}=\frac{32}{81}\pi R^3.

Final answer

r2=2Rhh2r^2=2Rh-h^2. The maximum volume occurs at h=4R3h=\dfrac{4R}{3}, r=223Rr=\dfrac{2\sqrt2}{3}R, and Vmax=3281πR3V_{\max}=\dfrac{32}{81}\pi R^3.

Marking scheme

1. Checkpoints (max 7 pts total)

  • Coordinate model (2 pts): Place the sphere as x2+y2+z2=R2x^2+y^2+z^2=R^2 with vertex at (0,0,R)(0,0,R).
  • Relation r(h)r(h) (2 pts): Derive r2=R2(Rh)2=2Rhh2r^2=R^2-(R-h)^2=2Rh-h^2.
  • Optimization (3 pts): Form V(h)V(h), differentiate, solve V(h)=0V'(h)=0, and compute h,r,Vmaxh,r,V_{\max}.

2. Zero-credit items

  • Guessing h=4R3h=\frac{4R}{3} without calculus or a valid extremum argument.
  • Using an incorrect relation between rr and hh.

3. Deductions

  • Derivative error (-1): incorrect V(h)V'(h).
  • Substitution error (-1): incorrect r2r^2 or VmaxV_{\max} after plugging h=4R3h=\frac{4R}{3}.
Ask AI ✨