MathIsimple

Solid Geometry – Problem 23: Find the ratio

Question

In triangular prism ABCA1B1C1ABC-A_1B_1C_1, the top face is a translation of the base, i.e. AA1=BB1=CC1.\overrightarrow{AA_1}=\overrightarrow{BB_1}=\overrightarrow{CC_1}. Plane ABC1ABC_1 cuts the prism into two pyramids: tetrahedron ABCC1ABCC_1 and quadrilateral pyramid C1ABB1A1C_1-ABB_1A_1. Find the ratio VABCC1:VC1ABB1A1.V_{ABCC_1}:V_{C_1-ABB_1A_1}.

Step-by-step solution

Use vectors (coordinates). Take AA as the origin. Let u=AB,w=AC,v=AA1.\vec u=\overrightarrow{AB},\qquad \vec w=\overrightarrow{AC},\qquad \vec v=\overrightarrow{AA_1}. Then B=A+uB=A+\vec u, C=A+wC=A+\vec w, and C1=C+v=A+w+vC_1=C+\vec v=A+\vec w+\vec v.

The volume of tetrahedron ABCC1ABCC_1 is VABCC1=16det(u,w,AC1)=16det(u,w,w+v).V_{ABCC_1}=\frac16\left|\det(\vec u,\vec w,\overrightarrow{AC_1})\right|= \frac16\left|\det(\vec u,\vec w,\vec w+\vec v)\right|. Since det(u,w,w)=0\det(\vec u,\vec w,\vec w)=0, this simplifies to VABCC1=16det(u,w,v).V_{ABCC_1}=\frac16\left|\det(\vec u,\vec w,\vec v)\right|. The prism volume is base-area ×\times height (triple product form): Vprism=12det(u,w,v).V_{\text{prism}}=\frac12\left|\det(\vec u,\vec w,\vec v)\right|. Hence the other pyramid has volume VC1ABB1A1=VprismVABCC1=(1216)det(u,w,v)=13det(u,w,v).V_{C_1-ABB_1A_1}=V_{\text{prism}}-V_{ABCC_1}=\left(\frac12-\frac16\right)\left|\det(\vec u,\vec w,\vec v)\right|=\frac13\left|\det(\vec u,\vec w,\vec v)\right|. Therefore VABCC1:VC1ABB1A1=16:13=1:2.V_{ABCC_1}:V_{C_1-ABB_1A_1}=\frac16:\frac13=1:2.

Final answer

VABCC1:VC1ABB1A1=1:2V_{ABCC_1}:V_{C_1-ABB_1A_1}=1:2.

Marking scheme

1. Checkpoints (max 7 pts total)

  • Vector setup (2 pts): Define u=AB,w=AC,v=AA1\vec u=\overrightarrow{AB},\vec w=\overrightarrow{AC},\vec v=\overrightarrow{AA_1} and express C1C_1.
  • Volume via triple product (3 pts): Write VABCC1=16det(u,w,v)V_{ABCC_1}=\frac16|\det(\vec u,\vec w,\vec v)| and Vprism=12det(u,w,v)V_{\text{prism}}=\frac12|\det(\vec u,\vec w,\vec v)|.
  • Ratio conclusion (2 pts): Subtract volumes and simplify to 1:21:2.

2. Zero-credit items

  • Treating the ratio as “obviously” 1:21:2 with no computation.
  • Using a 2D area argument without connecting to the prism’s height (vector v\vec v).

3. Deductions

  • Determinant sign/scale error (-1): losing the 16\frac16 vs 12\frac12 factors.
  • Vector miswrite (-1): using AC1=v\overrightarrow{AC_1}=\vec v instead of w+v\vec w+\vec v.
Ask AI ✨